"It would be great to get it going again," Newport Beach Historical Society president Bernie Svalstad told the Orange County Register after news broke that the Balboa Theater had sold. "Maybe we can be part of it. We'd love that."
Anyone who has walked down East Balboa Boulevard in the last three decades has heard some version of that hope before. The marquee at 707 E. Balboa Blvd. has gone dark and then come back to life on paper several times since the early 1990s. The building has always been cheap to buy, and every plan to finish it has cost far more. The October sale changes who is paying, and two things the new owners inherit make this round different from the last one: a building that has already been gutted and redesigned on paper, and a deed restriction that keeps theater and the performing arts as the building's purpose.
What Sold on October 23
The sale closed Friday, Oct. 23, 2026. According to Stu News Newport, the seller was a local family office and the buyer a local private real estate investor who plans to restore the building and bring back its role as a cultural and entertainment venue. The Daily Pilot, citing L.A. Business First, reported that the buyers are a local couple who paid just under $2 million. The seller was Balboa Theater Co. LLC, the company that bought the building from the city a decade ago.
The buyer's representative told the Daily Pilot that the family "has a long history of restoring historic landmarks across California," and that the goal is "to bring it back to its former glory as a theater with an elevated restoration." In the same article, detailed plans were still waiting on conversations and meetings with the City of Newport Beach.
To see why "former glory" is a bigger promise than it sounds, you have to know what is actually behind the facade.
Behind the Marquee, There Isn't Much Theater Left
The building opened in 1928 as the Ritz Theater. A city staff report from April 2022 lays out what happened after that. The Balboa Amusement Company ran it as a movie house until 1973, it showed adult films from 1973 to 1975, and by 1976 Landmark Theaters was running it as a regular cinema again. In its working years it held about 450 seats. In later years it became known for cult films and midnight screenings of The Rocky Horror Picture Show before it closed in the early 1990s.
Then the inside was taken apart. According to the city's 2022 staff report, the building had a seismic retrofit in 1994 and a complete interior demolition in 1998. That same year the city bought the property with federal Community Development Block Grant funds and leased it to the Balboa Performing Arts Theater Foundation.
The demolition also cost the building its standing with the state. A historical resources report the city commissioned from Chambers Group in 2014 found that the structure had been changed so much that it is not eligible for the California Register of Historical Resources. It is still listed as a locally recognized historic resource in the Historical Resources Element of Newport Beach's General Plan. Whoever restores it is restoring a facade, a story and a shell.
Every Revival So Far Has Stalled on the Cost of Finishing
For nearly 30 years, the price to own the building has stayed small next to the cost of finishing it.
| Year | What happened | The number | Reported by |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1997 | The Balboa Arts Theater Foundation agreed to buy the theater, as long as it could raise the purchase price within 10 months | $550,000 to buy, plus about $750,000 more for improvements | Los Angeles Times |
| 2000 | The planned opening was pushed back a year as planning reviews, ADA work and other expenses added up | $1.4 million raised, $3 million still needed | Daily Pilot |
| 2002 | A basement for dressing rooms and restrooms was dropped because the space sits below the water table | Estimate rose from $300,000 to $1.8 million | Daily Pilot |
| 2003 | The foundation set a fundraising goal for a 320-seat live theater | $2 million by 2005, toward a $6.5 million project | Los Angeles Times |
| 2015 | City staff estimated the cost of making the building usable for the community | $5.8 million | Daily Pilot |
| 2016 | The city sold the building to LAB Holding | $1 million | Daily Pilot |
| 2026 | The building sold to its current owners | Just under $2 million | Daily Pilot |
Across the foundation years, the project kept getting more expensive while donations came in slowly. In 2003 the Los Angeles Times described progress as fitful, with seismic work and surprise costs throwing off earlier schedules. The foundation had real support, including a $1 million gift from philanthropists Donna and John Crean that the Daily Pilot recalled in its 2026 story. Even so, the gap kept growing. In 2004 the city approved the foundation's full renovation with a rooftop deck, and the California Coastal Commission issued a coastal development permit. Demolition work started, but the foundation never raised enough to finish construction.
In 2015 the foundation's board disbanded. According to the Daily Pilot, the board pointed to the building's deterioration, community input, cost and feasibility, and it gave its remaining $175,000 to the city for future arts projects. The city sold the building the next year.
The new owners paid about twice what the building sold for in 2016. That price is still about a third of what city staff estimated in 2015 it would cost just to make the building usable.
The Building Has Already Been Redesigned Smaller
The private owners after 2016 learned the same lesson, and the plan changed shape as a result.
LAB's first proposal reached the Planning Commission in January 2018. It called for 264 seats, a café, a rebuilt facade and marquee, and a rooftop deck that would have raised the building to 48 feet. That height is above the 35-foot limit in the Shoreline Height Limitation Zone, as the Daily Pilot reported. The Newport Beach Independent reported that the item was pulled for more staff review. That proposal was later withdrawn.
The version the city approved on April 15, 2022 is a different kind of building. The staff approval describes an open-air performing arts and special event theater. The work would restore the exterior facade, recreate the historic marquee and remove the aging roof structure. Here is how it compares with the building's past:
- Seats: 208, down from 325 under the earlier permit and about 450 when it showed films. The overall occupancy cap is 261.
- Size: no added floor area, no rooftop deck and no increase in height.
- Café: an accessory café serving theater patrons and the public. It could open within an 8 a.m. to midnight window depending on the season, under a Type 47 liquor license.
- Limits: the main use has to stay a theater, events are limited to cultural, performing arts and related categories, and restaurant, bar and nightclub uses are not allowed.
The approval was handled as a change that substantially conforms to the 2004 use permit, not as a new permit, and every earlier condition stayed in place. Four years later the marquee is still dark. So the new owners start where no earlier buyer did: with a gutted shell, a smaller roofless design the city has already reviewed, and a list of conditions already written.
The Deed Restriction Keeps the Theater at the Center
When the city sold the property in 2016, it recorded a deed restriction to keep the theater use and its supporting uses in place permanently. The October sale carried that intent forward. As Stu News Newport described it, the property has to stay in theatrical, cultural, event-related or performing arts use, with complementary commercial uses allowed.
Commercial uses can be part of the building, but they have to support the theater, the way the café in the 2022 plan serves theater patrons and the public. Under that plan's conditions, the main use stays a theater and restaurant, bar and nightclub uses are not allowed. Anyone who buys the building is taking on the job of reopening a theater, with everything else built around that.
What to Watch for on East Balboa Boulevard
The next steps happen at City Hall. The buyer's representative told the Daily Pilot that the owners' detailed plans depend on meetings with the city. When a plan is filed, it will either follow the 2022 open-air design or bring a new one. The 2022 approval's conditions say the existing building permit has to be revised before construction begins. That revision is the first concrete sign to look for on the city's planning agendas.
Svalstad's offer to the Orange County Register points to a second thing to watch for: whether the new owners bring in the Newport Beach Historical Society, which has said it would like to help.
At Stephanie Young Group, we follow stories like the Balboa Theater because they shape what a Newport Beach street will feel like for years. If you'd like to talk about what's changing around Balboa Village and the Peninsula, or you just want to share your own memory of a night at the old theater, let's connect.